The Evidence for Outdoor Learning

by Eric Gonzalez-Payne

For adultsAges 2 to 16·Teaching practice·Guide
The Evidence for Outdoor Learning

Written because the claims made for outdoor learning are frequently stronger than the evidence, and overclaiming is what gets a programme dismissed.

What the evidence reasonably supports

Physical activity increases. Children move more outdoors than indoors, consistently and by a large margin. This is the least contested finding.

Attention and mood improve in the period following time in green space. The effect is measurable and short lived, which is an argument for frequency rather than for occasional trips.

Vocabulary and language use are richer in outdoor sessions with an adult who asks rather than tells. The driver appears to be the quality of interaction, not the setting itself.

Engagement improves, especially for children who struggle in seated classrooms. This shows up repeatedly in teacher reports and in observed time on task.

Knowledge of local ecology is dramatically better in children who spend regular time in one place. This is unsurprising and worth stating.

What the evidence does not support

That outdoor learning raises test scores in general. Some studies find effects, many do not, and the strongest claims usually come from small studies with weak controls.

That any single programme causes long term wellbeing outcomes. The measurement problems are severe.

That nature has a specific effect distinguishable from exercise, novelty and better adult child ratios. Disentangling those is genuinely hard and mostly has not been done.

Why honesty here is strategic

A teacher or principal who has read anything on this topic will discount your whole case the moment you overclaim. The defensible version, that it improves engagement, movement, language and local knowledge, is enough and is far more persuasive.

How to use this

Claim engagement, movement, language and knowledge of place. Do not claim attainment. Report your own data from your own setting, which is more convincing to a school than any national study.

Recording and Assessing Outdoor Learning explains how to gather that data.

Eric Gonzalez-Payne

Eric Gonzalez-Payne

Founder and curriculum author

Ed.M. in Educational Leadership, Harvard Graduate School of Education

Published by Empathy Global LLC

LinkedIn

For the full social and emotional learning programme, see the Empathy Curriculum at empathy.kids.